Broadway basketeers

How to Choose an Anniversary Gift by Year and Recipient

  |  

Anniversaries are about celebrating a shared journey, not finding the most expensive gift. Whether you are marking a first anniversary with a boyfriend or girlfriend, or celebrating decades of marriage as a husband and wife, the most meaningful presents are those that show thought, care, and personal connection.

 

This guide brings together traditional anniversary themes, modern gift ideas, and practical buying tips to help you choose something memorable. From personalized gifts to carefully curated gift baskets, even simple ideas can become truly special when chosen with intention.

 

On this page:

Traditions | Common Celebrations | Ideas by Recipient | Parents or Grandparents | Trips and Experiences | Personalized Gifts | FAQs

Traditional anniversary gifts by year

Each anniversary year has a traditional material and meaning associated with it. These themes are intended as inspiration rather than strict rules, and many people choose to interpret them in modern or personalized ways.

 

1st anniversary – Paper
Symbolizes the beginning of a new chapter. Popular gifts include handwritten notes, personalized prints, and photo books.

2nd anniversary – Cotton
Represents comfort and connection. Common gifts include throws, cushions, or personalized textiles.

3rd anniversary – Leather
Symbolizes strength and resilience. Leather journals, wallets, or keepsakes are popular choices.

4th anniversary – Fruit or flowers
Represents nourishment and growth. A gourmet fruit gift basket is a modern and practical interpretation.

5th anniversary – Wood
Symbolizes strength and stability. Wooden keepsakes, engraved decor, or themed gift boxes work well.

6th anniversary – Iron
Represents a solid foundation. Iron-inspired gifts or engraved items are often chosen.

7th anniversary – Wool or copper
Symbolizes warmth, luck, and durability. Gifts may include cozy items or copper-accented keepsakes.

8th anniversary – Bronze
Represents longevity and resilience.

9th anniversary – Pottery
Symbolizes a partnership shaped over time. Ceramic or personalized home items suit this year well.

10th anniversary – Tin or aluminum
Represents flexibility and durability after a decade together. Keepsake tins and curated gift baskets are popular choices.

Anniversary years most people celebrate

While every anniversary matters, some milestones are more commonly celebrated with gifts or experiences. Personalization allows you to honor tradition while keeping the gift relevant to the couple.

1st anniversary – Paper

  • Personalized prints with names and dates
  • A photo book capturing the first year together
  • A gift basket paired with a handwritten letter or printed keepsake

Paper-based gifts feel intimate and meaningful without being overwhelming.

5th anniversary – Wood

  • Engraved wooden keepsakes
  • Personalized home decor
  • A themed gift basket presented in a wooden-style crate or box

Subtle custom labels or messages help tie the gift back to the traditional theme.

10th anniversary – Tin or aluminum

  • Keepsake tins filled with notes or memories
  • A personalized anniversary gift basket with a message card
  • A combination of practical and sentimental items

Gift baskets work particularly well here, allowing several meaningful elements to be presented together.

25th anniversary – Silver

  • Personalized silver-toned keepsakes
  • Luxury food or drink gift baskets
  • Custom gift boxes marking a major milestone

Elegant, understated personalization feels especially appropriate for this anniversary.

50th anniversary – Gold

  • Heirloom-style personalized gifts
  • Family-focused gift baskets celebrating shared memories
  • Bespoke hampers curated to the couple’s tastes

For long marriages, gifts that reflect family, history, and togetherness tend to resonate most.

Anniversary gift ideas by recipient

Many people find it easier to choose an anniversary gift by thinking about who they are buying for rather than the number of years. This section breaks down gift ideas by recipient, style, and how preferences often change over time.

Gifts for your partner

Whether you are buying for a husband, wife, boyfriend, or girlfriend, the best anniversary gifts combine emotional meaning with something they will genuinely enjoy.

Gifts for men

Anniversary gifts for men often work best when they are practical, personalized, or experience-led.

  • Personalized gifts featuring names, dates, or short messages
  • Watches or accessories with engraving
  • Curated gift baskets with food, drink, or hobby-related items
  • Experience gifts linked to shared interests or quality time

Many men appreciate gifts that feel useful but still clearly mark the occasion. Personalization helps elevate practical items into something meaningful.

Gifts for women

Anniversary gifts for women often lean toward sentiment, presentation, and personal touches.

  • Jewelry with personalized elements
  • Keepsake gifts marking a specific milestone
  • Luxury gift baskets designed for relaxation or indulgence
  • Experience gifts paired with a physical keepsake or message card

Presentation plays a big role here. A thoughtfully presented personalized gift or curated basket can feel just as special as a single high-value item.

How sentiment changes over time

As relationships develop, the emotional meaning behind a gift often becomes more important than novelty.

  • Early anniversaries tend to focus on romance and excitement
  • Later anniversaries prioritize memories, shared history, and familiarity
  • Personalized gifts and anniversary gift baskets naturally suit long-term relationships

For husbands and wives celebrating many years together, gifts that acknowledge time spent together often feel more meaningful than decorative items.

Gifts for parents or grandparents

Buying anniversary gifts for parents or grandparents is usually about celebrating a shared life rather than romance alone.

  • Thoughtful and meaningful options
  • Family-focused personalized gifts such as photo books or timelines
  • Keepsakes featuring important dates and milestones
  • Curated gift baskets designed to be shared
  • Experience gifts such as meals or short breaks

Practicality and comfort often matter more than novelty, especially for milestone anniversaries.

Why personalization matters here

Personalized anniversary gifts:

  • Show care without feeling excessive
  • Honor long-term commitment
  • Feel appropriate for significant anniversaries such as 25 or 50 years

Experience gifts, photo gifts, and gift baskets work particularly well because they combine celebration with usability.

Gifts for couples

When buying for a couple, shared enjoyment is key. Safe but thoughtful choices include:

  • Neutral home decor for shared spaces
  • Food and drink gift baskets curated for two
  • Subscription gifts that extend the celebration

Avoid novelty items unless you know the couple very well. Versatility and presentation matter.

Experience-inspired gifting

Many buyers prefer gifts that feel experiential without complex planning.

  • Gift baskets designed for a night in
  • Hampers themed around dining, relaxation, or celebration
  • Personalized messages that frame the gift as shared time together

This gives couples flexibility while still feeling intentional.

Using humor and inside jokes

For couples you know well, a subtle reference to a shared joke or memory can add warmth.

This could include:

  • A phrase or nickname only you and the couple understand
  • A light reference to a shared experience or vacation
  • A small reminder of a funny moment from earlier in their relationship

Humor works best as a personal touch layered onto a quality gift, not as the main focus.

Buying guide tip

If you are unsure what to buy, choose a gift that:

  • Can be personalized
  • Can be shared
  • Feels appropriate for the length of the relationship

These three factors consistently result in gifts that feel thoughtful and well chosen.

Anniversary trips and experiences

For many couples, an anniversary trip feels more meaningful than a physical gift, particularly as the years go on. Trips create shared memories and often suit milestone anniversaries where the focus shifts from things to time together.

Short breaks and local experiences

Best for:

  • 1st to 5th anniversaries
  • Stressful periods or busy schedules

Why they work:

  • Easy to plan
  • Clearly focused on togetherness
  • Can be enhanced with a personalized gift basket before or after the trip

Sporting events or live entertainment

A great option for couples with shared interests.

Best for:

  • Couples with a strong shared hobby
  • Anniversaries that fall during a season or tour

Buying guide tip: Pair tickets with a small personalized gift or themed basket so there is something tangible to open on the day.

Weekend minibreaks

A classic anniversary choice that suits many budgets.

Best for:

  • 3rd to 9th anniversaries
  • Couples who enjoy exploring without committing to long travel

Popular ideas include city breaks, countryside escapes, and coastal weekends. These trips feel special without requiring significant time off work.

Milestone anniversary trips

As anniversaries reach double figures, trips often become more ambitious.

10-year anniversaries and beyond

Many couples see this as a moment to mark the relationship in a bigger way.

Popular choices include:

  • Longer European breaks
  • Luxury hotel stays
  • Experiences that have been talked about but never booked

At this stage, the trip itself becomes the main gift rather than an addition.

Significant milestones such as 25 or 50 years

These anniversaries often justify once-in-a-lifetime travel.

Ideas include:

  • Long-haul vacations
  • Cruises
  • Multigenerational trips involving family

For these celebrations, presentation and planning matter just as much as the destination.

Do you buy anniversary gifts for a boyfriend or girlfriend?

You can absolutely buy an anniversary gift for a boyfriend or girlfriend. Anniversary gifts are not just for married couples. They can be given to celebrate milestones in any committed relationship. Whether you are dating or married, celebrating your time together with a thoughtful gift is a meaningful way to show love and appreciation.

Personalized Anniversary Gifts 

Celebrate and commemorate a special milestone with a personalized anniversary gift. With our customized gift options, you’re sure to find the perfect customized anniversary gift at Broadway Basketeers. 

 

The Personalized Love Pillowcase Set includes two pillowcases that features an adorable design for the happy couple along with custom text. These pillowcases are made from a strong and durable material that will fit standard pillows.

Two white pillow cases on top of each other with black embroidered writing and gold embroidered surname with embroidered hearts around it in the centre of the pillow case

View Here

The Personalized Love Birds Wine Glass Set includes set includes two engraved wine glasses. These stunning glasses feature thinner bowls and straighter stems for a more modern and sleek style. Each glass in beautifully engraved with a love bird design and custom text.

Two wine glasses with etched couple name and date you choose, with small birds symbolising love

View Here

The Personalized Black and White Sherpa Blanket is the perfect gift for any anniversary. This cozy blanket is soft and smooth, and it can be customized with a family name to create an instant keepsake. 

black and white blanket draped over a sofa with a surname embossed in the middle

View Here

Anniversary Gift Ideas for Her

Treat the special women in your life to a special anniversary gift that she is sure to cherish for years to come. At Broadway Basketeers, you’re sure to find the perfect anniversary present for her.

 

If you’re looking for a memorable wine gift, the With Love Wine Gift Basket is the perfect choice for any anniversary or date night. Treat her to a crisp bottle of wine, an adorable teddy bear, and a grand assortment of gourmet delights. 

Brown and gold basket filled with different shaped sweet treats and a red bottle of wine

View Here

The Memories Lane Photo Gift Box features a stunning mahogany photo box that can display photos in the lid. Each box is also filled to the brim with a delicious assortment of gourmet treats. Once the treats have been enjoyed, the wooden memories box can be used as a keepsake box for special items, photos, or memories. 

Brown wooden box with five cut out windows filled with black and white family photos opening to reveal sweet treats

View Here

The Chocolate Delight Gift Basket is the perfect anniversary gift for anyone with a sweet tooth. This elegant gift basket is brimming with a delectable assortment of chocolates and treats that she is sure to love. 

Brown and gold basket filled with sweets and chocolates with a mesh bow and gift tag

View Here

Anniversary Gift Ideas for Him

Celebrate your special day with him with a thoughtful anniversary gift from Broadway Basketeers. With our wide selection of personalized anniversary gifts, you’re sure to find a great gift for him. 

 

The Personalized Initial Black Watch Box holds four large watches and features sleek matte black wood, a glass hinged top, and velour lining and pillows. Add a personal touch by engraving up to three initials on the glass. 

Black watch box with glass top and 4 watch spaces displaying 4 different watch styles

View Here

This exquisite Personalized Gold Rim Decanter is a timeless piece that adds a touch of sophistication to any bar or home setting. Crafted from premium glass with a luxurious gold rim, this decanter is as stylish as it is functional.

Large clear decanter sits on top of a wooden chopping block and has a gold rim for the stopper as well as name engraving on the front of the glass

View Here

Our Happy Anniversary Wine Gift is the perfect way to celebrate a special milestone with him. Displayed in a charming “Happy Anniversary” wooden box, this classy gift is sure to raise glasses. Each gift box includes a crisp bottle of wine to celebrate the special day. 

Wooden wine box is stood up holding a bottle of red wine. The box is engraved with gold and black happy anniversary writing, a gold bow and straw filling

View Here

Common anniversary buying questions

Do I need to follow traditional anniversary themes?
No. Traditional themes are a guide, not a requirement.

How much should I spend on an anniversary gift?
There is no set amount. The value of an anniversary gift comes from thought and relevance rather than price.

Is it acceptable to give a shared gift rather than individual ones?
Yes. Shared gifts are often preferred because they encourage time together.

What makes an anniversary gift feel special?
Personalization, presentation, and relevance to the relationship.

Are experience gifts better than physical gifts?
They work best when paired with a physical keepsake or personalized message.

What if I have left it until the last minute?
Digital vouchers, non-dated personalized messages, and ready-to-send gift baskets are all suitable last-minute options.

Should I include a card with an anniversary gift?
Yes. A thoughtful message often matters more than the gift itself.

 

Whether you’re celebrating your first anniversary or have been together for a few decades, you’re sure to find the perfect personalized gift to commemorate and celebrate your special day together. Every anniversary gift from Broadway Basketeers includes a free customizable gift message so you can wish your loved one a happy anniversary in your own words. 

Latest posts

About us

    Founded over 25 years ago, Broadway Basketeers has been manufacturing and selling gourmet gift baskets to customers and businesses alike across the USA and Canada. By sticking to their core values, Broadway Basketeers has risen to become a leader in the gift basket industry.

Stay Connected

Sign up for our newsletter
Sign up for our Newsletter to be the first to know about Exclusive Offers, Exciting New Products & Upcoming Events.
Subscribe for exclusive offers
Receive limited, email-only offers
We love to socialize
Come join us on social media!
Shopping Cart (0)
Close
Your shopping cart is empty
Subtotal
$0.00
Checkout
Notification
Close
73% of our customers have got a reminder
Set a reminder below and never forget an important occasion again!
Get 10% off on your next order when you set 3 reminders!
*Discounts apply for new users only
*Terms & conditions apply
chat with us