Broadway basketeers

The Best Gifts for People Who Have Everything: Thoughtful & Unique Ideas

  |  

Why It’s So Hard to Buy for Someone Who Has Everything

Finding the right gift for someone who seems to already have everything can feel like an impossible task. You might scroll endlessly, hoping for inspiration to strike, only to realise that anything you choose could end up unused, duplicated, or politely shelved.

 

It’s not that they’re ungrateful, in fact, they’re often the people who insist they “don’t need anything.” But that’s what makes it so tricky. Traditional gifts don’t feel appropriate, and you’re left searching for something that feels thoughtful, personal, and different.

 

Whether it’s a milestone birthday, Christmas, or a special thank you, buying for someone who has it all takes a little extra imagination. But with the right approach, it’s far from impossible.

 

What Makes a Great Gift for Someone Who Has Everything?

When you're shopping for someone who's notoriously “hard to buy for”, the key is to shift your mindset. Instead of thinking about what they need, think about what might delight, surprise or connect with them on a more personal level.

 

A great gift for someone who has everything isn’t necessarily expensive or extravagant, it’s something that shows thought. This could mean a gift tied to a shared memory, something personalised with their name or interests, or even an experience that creates a new memory altogether.

 

Think beyond the obvious:

  • What do they enjoy doing in their spare time?
  • Is there something they wouldn’t typically buy for themselves?
  • Could you introduce them to something new or unexpected?

Ultimately, the best gifts for hard-to-buy-for people are those that reflect your understanding of who they are, not just what they own.

 

Top Gift Ideas for People Who Have Everything

When you’re shopping for someone who’s hard to buy for, a carefully chosen gift basket can strike the perfect balance between thoughtful and indulgent. Here are some standout ideas based on personality, interests, and occasion:

 

For the Foodie: Royal Heights Gift Tower

A treat for the senses, this elegant tower is filled with gourmet goodies and is perfect for someone who appreciates fine snacks and beautiful presentation. Great for birthdays, thank yous or simply to surprise a food lover.

Royal Heights Gift Tower

 

For the Celebrator: Celebration Gift Tower

Packed with sweets, nuts and chocolates, this vibrant gift tower is made for someone who enjoys hosting, entertaining, or simply snacking in style. It’s bold, joyful, and full of variety.

Celebration Gift Tower with Sweets Nuts and Chocolates

 

For the Sophisticated Palate: Premium Wine & Chocolate Gift Box

This refined pairing is ideal as a thank you gift or a gesture of appreciation. With a carefully selected wine and artisan chocolates, it feels luxurious without being over the top.

Premium Wine & Chocolate Gift Box

 

For Life’s Big Moments: Warm Wishes Wine Basket

Mark a milestone with this celebratory gift. Whether it’s a new job, a house move or a big birthday, this wine gift basket delivers a mix of elegance and warmth.

Warm Wishes Wine Gift Basket

 

For the Thoughtful Couple: Personalised Coaster Set

When someone already has everything, a personalised touch can go a long way. This engraved couples’ coaster set adds charm to their home and is perfect for weddings, anniversaries or housewarmings.

Personalized Couple's Coaster Set

 

For the Sentimental One: Memories Lane Photo Gift Box

This is a lovely way to give something that’s both meaningful and beautifully packaged. Fill it with printed photos or keepsakes to make the gift truly personal.

Memories Lane Photo Gift Box

Experience Gifts: Give a Memory, Not More Stuff

When someone already has plenty of “things,” the most meaningful gift you can give is often an experience, something that creates a memory rather than adds more clutter. Experience gifts are thoughtful, personal, and often more impactful than anything you could wrap.

 

Whether it’s a luxury spa day, tickets to a concert, or a private cooking class, experiences can be tailored to suit someone’s passions and personality. They also show that you've taken the time to think about what they enjoy – not just what’s available online.

Here are a few experience gift ideas to inspire you:

  • Theatre or event tickets for a night out they’ll remember
  • Cooking classes for food lovers or aspiring chefs
  • Spa or massage vouchers to help them unwind
  • Creative workshops like pottery, painting or photography
  • Weekend escapes or mini-adventures for couples or close friends
  • Subscription services like audiobook memberships or curated book boxes
  • VIP experiences – think wine tastings, behind-the-scenes tours or hot air balloon rides

The beauty of experience gifts is their flexibility. Many can be booked last minute, sent digitally, or chosen by the recipient if you’re not quite sure what they’d prefer. And best of all, they don’t gather dust on a shelf.

 

Tips for Choosing the Right Gift (Even When They Say They Don’t Want Anything)

We’ve all heard it: “Don’t get me anything!” While it might sound like a polite refusal, it often just means the person doesn’t want something generic or unnecessary. But that doesn’t mean they won’t appreciate a thoughtful surprise.

 

Here are a few tips to help you choose something meaningful, even for the most resistant gift recipient:

Think about their lifestyle, not just their interests

Do they travel a lot? Work from home? Love to cook but never have time? A gift that supports how they live day to day often feels more thoughtful than something purely decorative.

Listen for clues in conversation

People drop hints all the time without realising. They might mention a book they’ve been meaning to read, a restaurant they want to try, or a hobby they’ve always wanted to pick up. Keep an ear out and take note.

Go practical but elevated

Useful gifts don’t have to be boring. Think of a premium version of something they already use or something you think they could use! Gift baskets are another brilliant option – they’re practical, easy to personalise, and packed with treats they can actually enjoy. 

Avoid the “stuff” trap

Ask yourself: Will this add value to their life, or just take up space? If you’re unsure, an experience, personalised item, or edible treat is usually a safer (and more appreciated) choice.

Even the most “un-giftable” people will appreciate something that’s been chosen with care. And if in doubt? A handwritten card and a kind gesture can be just as powerful as a physical gift.

 

It’s Not About the Gift, It’s About the Thought

When you’re buying for someone who has everything, the pressure to find something perfect can feel overwhelming. But the truth is, the best gifts aren’t about price tags or novelty – they’re about connection.

 

Whether it’s a curated gift basket filled with their favourite treats, a personalised keepsake, or an experience they’ll remember, the most meaningful gifts show that you’ve taken the time to think about who they are and what brings them joy.

 

At the end of the day, it’s the thought behind the gift that really counts. It’s about saying “I see you,” “I know you,” and “I care.” And that, more than anything you could wrap in paper, is what makes a gift truly special.

 

If you’re still looking for inspiration, take a look at our best-selling gift baskets, handpicked favourites that are guaranteed to impress.
 

Latest posts

The Hidden Meaning Behind the Gifts We Give

Geraldine Milne | Jun 7 2025

What to Write in a Father’s Day Card

Geraldine Milne | May 22 2025

10 Best Father’s Day Gift Baskets

Geraldine Milne | May 19 2025

10 Best Mother’s Day Gift Basket Ideas

Geraldine Milne | Apr 28 2025

What to Write in a Mother’s Day Card

Geraldine Milne | Apr 28 2025

Top 10 Best Birthday Gift Baskets

Geraldine Milne | Apr 21 2025

Top 10 Best Sympathy Gift Baskets

Geraldine Milne | Apr 21 2025

About us

    Founded over 25 years ago, Broadway Basketeers has been manufacturing and selling gourmet gift baskets to customers and businesses alike across the USA and Canada. By sticking to their core values, Broadway Basketeers has risen to become a leader in the gift basket industry.

Stay Connected

Sign up for our newsletter
Sign up for our Newsletter to be the first to know about Exclusive Offers, Exciting New Products & Upcoming Events.
Subscribe for exclusive offers
Receive limited, email-only offers
We love to socialize
Come join us on social media!
chat with us